Ahmedabad Flight Crash Reason: Resembles Miracle on the Hudson without Miracle

Reading Time: 5 min
Ahmedabad Flight Crash Reason

Ahmedabad Flight Crash Reason – What We Know So Far

On June 12, 2025, Air India Flight 171, a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner, crashed just moments after takeoff from Ahmedabad Airport en route to London Gatwick. The aircraft carried 230 passengers and 12 crew members. Tragically, at least 260 people, including several on the ground, lost their lives.

Only one passenger survived the crash—Viswashkumar Ramesh, a British national, who described the horror:

“30 seconds after takeoff there was a loud noise, and then the plane crashed… There were bodies all around me.”

This catastrophe is one of India’s deadliest aviation disasters. But what exactly caused it?

Table of Contents

💥 Was It a Dual Engine Failure?

Initial speculation suggests a possible dual engine failure, but no official cause has been confirmed yet. Investigators are analyzing the black box and cockpit voice recorder (CVR) to determine what went wrong.

Expert Opinions Vary:

  • ✈️ Some believe bird strikes may have caused both engines to flame out.
  • 🛠️ Others suggest a mechanical fault or maintenance issue.
  • ⚠️ A few experts argue dual engine failure is so rare that other causes should also be explored.

🔧 What is Dual Engine Failure?

Dual engine failure refers to the complete loss of power in both engines of an aircraft. This is extremely rare in commercial aviation.

📉 How Rare Is It?

  • Occurs in less than 1 in a billion flight hours.
  • Aircraft engines are built with isolated systems, so failure in one does not usually affect the other.
  • Pilots undergo intense simulator training for such emergencies.

🔍 Common Causes:

  • 🐦 Bird strikes (as with US Airways Flight 1549)⛽ Fuel exhaustion or contamination
  • 🌩️ Severe weather (hail, ash clouds)
  • ⚙️ Mechanical faults or maintenance errors
  •  

✈️ How Planes Handle Engine Failure

 Aircraft like the Boeing 787 and Airbus A320 are designed to glide for miles even without power.

Key Safety Measures:

  • ✅ Dual redundant systems
  • ✅ Emergency power units
  • ✅ Gliding capability
  • ✅ Onboard computer assistance
  • ✅ Trained human intervention

Pilots are trained to:

  • Stabilize the aircraft
  • Search for emergency landing options
  • Communicate with Air Traffic Control

 

🎥 The Miracle on the Hudson: A Dual Engine Failure Case Study

Perhaps the most well-known case of a dual engine failure in commercial aviation occurred during US Airways Flight 1549 on January 15, 2009. This real-life event became a defining moment in aviation history and later inspired the Hollywood film Sully, starring Tom Hanks.

What Happened:

  • Shortly after takeoff from LaGuardia Airport, New York, the Airbus A320 encountered a flock of Canada geese.
  • Both engines ingested birds, causing an immediate dual engine failure at just 2,800 feet.
  • With no engine power and limited altitude, the pilot Captain Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger and First Officer Jeffrey Skiles had only seconds to react.
  • Unable to return to LaGuardia or divert to nearby airports, Sully made the split-second decision to ditch the plane in the Hudson River.
  • The aircraft successfully landed on the river’s surface, and thanks to the crew’s calm, decisive actions, all 155 passengers and crew survived.
  • The event is now famously known as The Miracle on the Hudson.”

Why It Matters:

  • This case shows how rare dual engine failures can still happen—and how critical pilot training and calm under pressure are to survival.
  • It also highlights the importance of bird strike prevention, a key focus in airport safety protocols today.

Relevance to the Ahmedabad Crash:

While the Air India 171 crash is still under investigation, many are drawing early comparisons to Flight 1549 due to the suspected dual engine failure and the timing—just minutes after takeoff. However, unlike the Miracle on the Hudson, 171 did not have the altitude or circumstances to enable an emergency glide or controlled crash landing, leading to the tragic outcome.

🗂️ Other Confirmed Dual Engine Failures

FlightDateCauseOutcome
Scandinavian Airlines 751Dec 27, 1991Ice ingestionAll 129 survived
Dana Air 0992June 3, 2012Unknown engine fault165 fatalities
Centurion Air Cargo 164July 7, 2008Engine #1 and #4 failedCrew survived; 2 ground deaths

📉 Why Are Dual Failures So Unlikely?

  • Engines are independent systems.
  • Fuel, electrical, and control lines are duplicated.
  • Bird strikes or other causes must affect both engines simultaneously, which is extremely rare.

🧾 What Caused the Ahmedabad Flight Crash?

Although not confirmed, a dual engine failure is being considered. Some experts point toward:

  • Possible bird strike during takeoff
  • Sudden loss of engine power, which prevented the aircraft from gaining altitude
  • Maintenance oversight or technical fault

Black box data and voice records are under analysis. Results will tell if this tragedy was avoidable.

💰 Tata Group's Response to the Tragedy

In the wake of the disaster, Tata Group, which owns Air India, announced:

  • ₹1 crore compensation for each victim’s family.
  • Medical care for the injured
  • Full support to the investigation
  • Reconstruction of B J Medical Hostel nearby

While this financial support is commendable, many are questioning:

Could the crash have been prevented?

🤔 Who Is to Blame?

 

It’s too early to say. The aircraft’s captain had significant flight hours and experience. The crash occurred within 2–3 minutes of takeoff, leaving little time for decision-making.

The investigation will answer:

  • Were the engines in proper condition?
  • Were safety inspections skipped?
  • Was human error involved?
  • Could a Sully-like decision have saved lives?

✅ Final Thoughts

The Ahmedabad Flight Crash Reason is still under investigation. While dual engine failure is rare, this tragedy resembles the Miracle on the Hudson—only without the miracle. Whether it’s mechanical negligence, bird strike, or human error, one thing is clear: aviation safety must remain a top priority.

This tragic event serves as a wake-up call. With better protocols, training, and timely decisions—many lives could be saved in the future.

FAQ

Q1. What happened in the Ahmedabad Flight Crash on June 12, 2025?

The Air India Flight 171, a Boeing 787-8 Dreamliner, crashed shortly after takeoff from Ahmedabad en route to London, killing at least 260 people. Only one passenger survived.

No, the cause is not confirmed. Dual engine failure is a strong possibility but will only be verified after black box and CVR analysis.

It refers to the simultaneous loss of power in both engines of an aircraft, which is extremely rare in modern aviation.

According to global aviation data, it happens in less than 1 in a billion flight hours.

  • US Airways Flight 1549 (“Miracle on the Hudson”)
  • Scandinavian Airlines Flight 751
  • Dana Air Flight 0992
  • Centurion Air Cargo Flight 164

Modern aircraft are designed to glide without engine power and pilots are trained in simulators to handle such emergencies.

Viswashkumar Ramesh described a loud noise 30 seconds after takeoff, followed by the crash, with bodies around him when he regained consciousness.

Tata Group announced ₹1 crore compensation for each deceased’s family, medical support for the injured, and rebuilding of B J Medical’s hostel nearby.

Answer: The Dreamliner is a twin-engine wide-body aircraft with advanced fuel efficiency and electronic systems. More details can be found on Boeing’s official page.

While it’s mentioned the captain had high flight experience, the specific names, flight hours, or background were not disclosed in public reports yet.

Answer: ATC provides emergency support and clearances for landing, coordinates with rescue teams, and helps ensure a crash site is secured.

Tata Group announced ₹1 crore compensation for each deceased’s family, medical support for the injured, and rebuilding of B J Medical’s hostel nearby.

Includes site preservation, black box recovery, maintenance history analysis, interviews, and an official final report by DGCA or a national body.

Historically, major crashes often lead to safety mandates, design changes, and stricter maintenance rules.

Investigation will include inspection logs, recent repairs, and last checks to see if technical error or negligence played a role.

 

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *